Use Duct Tape and You May Go To Jail

83

By mljdgulley354

Inspiration from Hubbers

Reading works of other hubbers, I have learned one way of finding topics to write about is reading newspaper stories. This morning as I was browsing the “news” on the internet, I came across a story of a couple being put in jail for duct taping their two children’s mouths, hands together, and feet together.

Reflection on CNN Reporter Story

I was actually disappointed in the reporter’s story. Maybe they only have space for a 150 to 200 word article. I don’t know. What I do know the reporter left a great deal of information out of the story in my opinion. But what they did say I would like to recap.

Police: Arizona parents duct tape kids, post photos on Facebook

The couple posted these pictures on the internet, specifically Facebook. OK. So if the intent of this couple was to abuse their children, would they have posted such pictures on the internet? The story goes on to say the two children were smiling. Does children smiling sound like children being abused. The mom states, she is a stay at home mom and this was just for fun.

I would really liked to know the real story of how this couple ended up in jail. Inappropriate pictures of children posted on the internet, you say. Well that response brought to mind an accepted television show called “America’s Funniest Home Videos”. I don’t know if my readers have watched that show but what I have seen in the capacity of “funny” children adventures, I would have to say duct tape was pretty mild. I have watched children get knocked down by a dog, fall head first into a wading pool, take a tremendous crash on their bicycle, be run over by bigger brother or sister while riding a bicycle and this is funny. Who knows the duct tape story could have been a couple trying to make an “America’s Funniest Home Video”.

No where in this story did it say this was a discipline tactic the parents were using. However, according to the comments shared below the story, readers jumped to the conclusion this was a way to discipline their children. One comment mentioned, “how can parents abuse their children like that?”

Source: ClipartOf.com

Taking a Trip With Bickering Kids

I will share my two experiences with duct tape. The first was when my sister and I were traveling with her one child, five of my children and oldest grandson (3months). We were making a nine hour trip.

Two hours away from our destination we were tired and all the kids were tired. Cramped quarters for seven hours can definitely fray the nerves of adults and kids alike. We took advantage of a rest area, giving everyone time to run around and warning them we didn’t want to hear anymore bickering when we got back in the car.

Of course this warning lasted for about 20 more miles before the bickering started again. Luckily there was one more rest area before our destination, so once again we stopped and let everyone run around hoping we could settle the tribe down. Back in the car and another few miles, the bickering escalated to unheard of cymbals. My sister stopped the car and grabbed a roll of duct tape and proceeded to tape mouths shut and making the culprits hold hands, taped hands together. The rest of the trip was actually quiet.

When we arrived at my uncle’s and began letting the kids out of the car, taking the duct tape off as they got out, my uncle had come out to greet us and was horrified at what we had done. This was the same uncle that had threatened me and my sister with a razor strap when we were bickering as we grew up.

“Well, that’s not the same thing,” he said to us. In my mind yet today, being swatted with a razor strap is a whole lot worse than duct tape

The Jabbering of a Baby

I would like to share a little background about this particular grandchild before I share my next duct tape experience.

This little tyke began arguing before he could speak words. When he learned to crawl he would get behind my husband’s recliner and when asked to come out, he would sit and jabber at my husband and me. Of course he would not come out until one of us physically dragged him out. This little guy had no problem from the beginning letting anyone who would listen or not listen what he thought.

I remember putting him in his high chair, putting peas on the tray so he could pick them up himself and eat them. At first he pushed the peas around on the tray jabbering at the all the while. Then he would pick them up one by one and drop them to the floor, saying “uh, oh” each time until they were on the floor all around his high chair. We might have been a bit dense, but we did figure out he did not like peas.

We had the joy of spending a lot of time with this little guy and his brother due to their dad’s work and their mom’s ill health.

Some Think Funny Some Think Horrifying

The boys went to stay with my eldest daughter while their dad was working close to where they lived. It was getting close to Christmas, they needed to do some Christmas shopping. The shopping area was about fifteen miles from their home.

“Mom, that child talked the whole way,” my daughter told me later. “We purposely waited until the afternoon, thinking the boys would take a nap on the way. That did not happen.”

By the time they did get into town, my son-in-law turned to Gabby and said, “We don’t want to forget the duct tape.”

“Oh no you don‘t,” Hotrod exclaimed, “you’re not putting duct tape on my mouth.” He was two years old. No one to that point had used duct tape on his mouth, or had even threatened to do so, but he sure knew what it was for.

Today his dad calls him “Hotrod” for good reason. He earned that name very early in life. He has a motor mouth and one speed, HIGH gear, yet today, and he is now 15 years old.

My point is, what some people think is funny, other people think the same incident is horrifying.

Comments

Brett Winn profile image

Brett Winn Level 4 Commenter 4 months ago

I agree. I wrote an article about the duct tape recently and in researching, kept coming across photos where people had taped their babies to the wall. I was horrified! I can only imagine what other scary uses poor parents might come up with. Glad you're bring awareness to this! Voted up!

Brett Winn profile image

Brett Winn Level 4 Commenter 4 months ago

There needs to be an "important" button, as well as the others, I would click it for this article!

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

Brett thank you for reading this. I am horrified as well but think $$ and time of our police force and court system is not being used as well as it could be. There is so much worse out there they need to tend too. Obviously these two little ones were not being subjected to really harmful things like meth or neglected because their parents are all doped up. This is a never ending battle it seems though so maybe officers needed a break.

tlpoague profile image

tlpoague Level 7 Commenter 4 months ago

I remember that trip. As horrible as it sounds, you should check with the kids to see who ended up with the picture taken. I remember Rooster laughing at Auntie, while the others didn't think it was fair that they were in trouble for Rooster starting the bickering.

I couldn't believe Hotrod remembered telling me that. I was embarrassed when the elderly lady stopped to glare at me and give him a pity look. She thought I was a terrible mother, even after I tried to explain that he was my nephew and I would never think of doing something like that.

Another great hub!

jessicakennedy profile image

jessicakennedy 4 months ago

I did that to my friend once, although I duct taped her to a chair and put her in a closet. At the time, I didn't think to take pictures of it! Darn!

moiragallaga profile image

moiragallaga Level 6 Commenter 4 months ago

Very interesting hub mljdgulley354 and you raise several very important points. Proper context is required before we make any judgments and there are other more pressing concerns that police should attend to. One thing for sure though, duct tape is really very useful. There's always a ready supply in our home, hehe. :-)

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

Gabby I might have left some of that story out about hotrod. I just remember how funny your telling about the incident was. Just remembering him at that age and how astute he was makes me laugh.

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

Jessica I almost made that comment about the fact the parents didn't put them in a closet after they duct taped them in my hub. How funny.

moiragallaga thank you for stopping by. I still keep duct tape in the car because it has so many uses as well as in the garden shed and home. lol

Cardisa profile image

Cardisa Level 8 Commenter 4 months ago

I haven't seen the duct tape story but I would love to see those pictures to determine for myself what happened. I doubt that someone abusing kids would post damning photos of the act.

Thanks for sharing this.

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

Cardisa, I guess the police removed the pictures from FB when they arrested the parents. I couldn't reconcile posting pictures if you were abusing your kids either. I feel like this is pretty minor for law enforcement to be spending tax dollars and time on though.

kelleyward profile image

kelleyward Level 7 Commenter 4 months ago

Wow that is scary. I can't imagine feeling duct tape was my best response to parenting, although there are many times I would love some peace and quiet. ha ha

weezyschannel profile image

weezyschannel Level 4 Commenter 4 months ago

It amazes me how we have go be afraid to discipline kids nowadays. A very long time ago a friend of mine literally watches children being abused so she calls protective services. They don't do a thing. Said there was no abuse since there were no scars. Needless to say there were 7 children in the home and she gave everyone up for adoption less than a year later and she was questioned over and over on why she called. She was the criminal

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

kelleyward thank you for stopping by. We felt duct tape on that trip was the lesser of the evils since all six kids were getting pretty roudy and distractive with out let up.

weezyschannel I have turned people in who were very much abusing there children and got the same response. Maybe that is why I was so incensed over this story.

phankinson profile image

phankinson Level 1 Commenter 4 months ago

I cant tell you how many times i have wanted to tape my kids, i threaten to tape them and throw them in the closet. but i never have. but the story does bring back memories of when i was tormenting beaner and her friend and they all carried me outside and taped me to the light pole in the yard. i had to get out of it myself. anyway after reading this story i'm afraid to post my xmas pics. i tied my kids up with garland and made them stand in front of the tree for pics.

mena7thefamily profile image

mena7thefamily 4 months ago

I remember that story. It is so much going on out here! That was very cute about your grand baby. As always a good helpful hub. Keep them coming. Thank you!

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

phankinson, your kids were having fun being wrapped up but I would suggest not posting the pictures on the internet.

mena7thefamily, thank you for that wonderful comment, it is always a joy to find you reading and commenting on my little stories.

Frank Atanacio profile image

Frank Atanacio Level 8 Commenter 4 months ago

a very good share.. really I had to vote up and awesome.. the only buttons available :)

stricktlydating profile image

stricktlydating Level 5 Commenter 4 months ago

I read the article and found it disterbing. I felt like - Thankgoodness for Facebook so the parents were caught. The little girl she was playing the 'duct tape' game with was only 10 months old - A baby of this age often cannot walk or talk and I believe while the mother may have found it 'funny' to ductape her baby I'm pretty sure the child would not have found it funny at all. I think any way you look at it it's abuse, and I don't think you can compare it to funny home video's. Authorities said the pictures were so disturbing they could not release them. Babies have short memories too, smiling after the situation was over does not mean they found the duct tape fun.

brittneyandtrent 4 months ago

i went to jail last week...guess you cant duct tape your girl ....... :(

brittneyandtrent 4 months ago

stricklydating..wow embarassing how you spell disterbing wrong. here's a quarter, buy a clue.

brittneyandtrent 4 months ago

oops, disturbing...

muahahhahahhahahahahahahaha

can i tag dolores?

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

Thank you strictlydating for stopping by and reading this story. I actually agree with you that this action really isn't appropriate but it does make me wonder about the definition of abuse. What some see as abuse others see as humorous and not having been on the scene I hate to make a judgement. What does it mean the pictures were so disturbing the authorities wouldn't release them?

Yes brittneyandtrent

phdast7 profile image

phdast7 Level 8 Commenter 4 months ago

Fun Hub. It is interesting how opinions have changed on what is and isn't child abuse. I am one of four children. When we were 9, 6,5, and 4, my poor mother had to herd all four of onto a plane and travel from New York to Athens, Greece.

For safety as well as for her sanity she put the two youngest children into a little harness (with straps that fit across the chest) that had a leash attached. Regardless of how bad it might have looked to others, how else could one woman make sure her four children didn't get lost, wander off, or stumble into traffic. Maybe she should have duct taped us together. :)

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

phdast, thank you for reading and commenting on this story. I have used the harness thing too. With five children a mother has to do some drastic things to keep them all together. My children don't look at some of those things I had to do as being abusive. Thank Goodness because some people do see those things as abusive to children.

brittneyandtrent 4 months ago

we are so confused on how to use hub pages. WE ARE SO CONFUSED. Yes brittneyandtrent? WHAT KINDA ANSWER IS THAT?

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

Sorry brittneyandtrent about that short response, you asked a question that I didn't understand and that should have been my response. We don't tag anyone here on hubpages. Go to the learning center and you can find out how to get started on hubpages. There are a number of hubs posted for new hubbers to help explain getting started.

brittneyandtrent 4 months ago

THANKS!!!

homesteadbound profile image

homesteadbound Level 8 Commenter 4 months ago

The parents were somewhat stupid in posting the pictures for the world to see. If it was in fun, there are too many people who will misunderstand. If not, then it truly is very stupid. Sometimes people just do not think.

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

I agree homesteadbound, parents today think nothing of how the world views their internet postings. Thank you for reading and commenting

CloudExplorer profile image

CloudExplorer Level 8 Commenter 4 months ago

Yes this hub is cool, I liked the duck tape part of the hub, where you was inspired to write, due to that absent minded reporter. Those reporters are always short changing us somehow, lol.

I actually like your peas story as well with the little guy, dropping some on the floor, showing signs of refusal to ingest such healthy items. Your hub was interesting to say the least.

Thanks for sharing such a fun hub with us, voted up, I have no clue what inspires me to write.

I just keep writing & the ideas keep flowing I guess, and I also created a title list of hubs to come for the future on some scrap paper, maybe that could help you as well. You can also write entire hubs as responses to questions in the Q&A area, now thats fun!

Oh and thanks for visiting me recently I just made it back to you @ mljdgulley354, can't wait to read more from you.

molometer profile image

molometer Level 8 Commenter 4 months ago

I have seen America’s Funniest Home Videos and cannot believe some of the things on that show.

An innocent picture taken out of context can easily be misinterpreted, as seems to be the case here.

We have all learned a lot from this hub, well done for bringing it to a wider audience.

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 4 months ago

Thank you CloudExplorer for stopping and reading my stories. It has been a fun experience here on hubpages. Thanks for the tips on writing ideas.

molometer I love having you read and comment on my stories. Thank you so much

alocsin profile image

alocsin Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

Who knew that duct tape could break the law. Voting this Up and Interesting.

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 3 months ago

alocsin, thank you for stopping and reading my story. It is amazing how many stories I have run across that duct tape is being used as an example of abuse by media and the law enforcement.

cclitgirl profile image

cclitgirl Level 7 Commenter 3 months ago

Great hub! I think sometimes our society goes way overboard in pointing out abuse...and leaves many parents wondering if they discipline their children if they will go to jail. Though this isn't a story of discipline, it's a testament to how people can overreact - too easily. In any case, I also have to say that I've been enjoying your comments on other hubs. I just love your insight, mljdgulley354. Keep on keepin' on. :)

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 3 months ago

Thank you cclitgirl for your wonderful comment. You may have just inspired another hub. Have to see if I can get it to flow. Thanks again.

le 3 months ago

Just came across this page. Wondering if any body who sounds to gung ho about duct tape here feels the same way now that the story in CA is out of a teacher duct taping his students - they thought it was a game too. Gosh, guess that means it wasn't so bad. -according to these posters

mljdgulley354 profile image

mljdgulley354 Hub Author 3 months ago

Don't know about the incident in CA do you have alink to yhat story?

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working